Kate Schaefer (kate_schaefer) wrote,
Kate Schaefer
kate_schaefer

I am/je suis Charlie Hebdo/Ahmed Merabet/Daniel Pearl/Marcela Yarce/Malala Yousafzai/Ali Ferzat

I am Charlie Hebdo. Why am I Charlie Hebdo?

I am Charlie Hebdo because I sometimes say outrageous things, and I have the right -- I believe very strongly that I have the right -- to say those outrageous things. I have the right to say those outrageous things even if they are stupid and offensive, even if I am wrong to say those things.

I am not Charlie Hebdo because I think I should not say those outrageous things. I think I should not offend my neighbors. And yet I believe -- I believe very strongly -- that I have the right to offend my neighbors, and that sometimes I must offend my neighbors.

I am Ahmed Merabet because I defend my right to say outrageous things, and your right to say outrageous things, and everyone's right to say outrageous things. I am Ahmed Merabet because I defend your right to say things that outrage me, and your right to go on living in freedom after you say those things. I am Ahmed Merabet because I am not brave enough to be Ahmed Merabet in truth, but I am brave enough to call out his bravery. It was simple bravery in the course of doing his job, and he died doing that job, which included protecting -- trying to protect -- people who insulted the things in which he believed.

And while I am claiming solidarity with people who were braver than I am and who are now dead, I will also claim to be a slain American journalist and a slain Mexican journalist and a living Pakstani schoolgirl shot in her face and a living Syrian cartoonist with both hands broken. I cannot be as brave as any of them, or at least I have not been called to be as brave as any of them. All I do now is to say that I see their bravery, and I hope that if I should face any of the impossible, horrible conditions they faced, I could face them as bravely as they did, even though I fear that I could not. I witness their lives and their suffering and I claim solidarity with them, knowing that to do so is equal parts pompous and humble.
Subscribe

  • Leaving LJ

    Like many others, I have left LJ. I've set up an account at Dreamwidth under the same name, kate_schaefer. I've imported the entries from this…

  • Remembering Kate Yule

    Kate Yule played with her words, all the time. Puns and other plays on words (and she knew the difference between kinds of wordplay), capped…

  • Especially for replyhazy

    I'm traveling next week, so this week I'm making a purse for my mother (who is going abroad this summer for the first time in her adult life) similar…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 2 comments